• Will Sweat Harm My Harness?
  • Should You Use Rope or Webbing to Connect to an Anchor?
  • Choosing Between C4s and Friends
  • Can You Lead On a Static Rope?
  • Can I Use Climbing Bolts For Anchors in a Gym?
  • Are Falls Held or Breaking Strength More Important In a Rope?
  • Does Poop Harm a Climbing Rope?
  • Are Homemade Draws Reliable?
  • Shopping for Economy Carabiners
  • When You Fly, Can You Carry On Climbing Gear?
  • Can I Trust Fixed Draws?
  • Which Helmet WIll Fit My Big Head?
  • Choosing Ice Screw Length
  • Are Adjustable Leg Loops Useful?
  • Should I clip ice screws with Screamers?
  • How do I Make a Bomber Anchor?
  • Can I Modify my Crampon Without Compromising the Integrity?
  • Hot Versus Cold Forging
  • Caring For Your FIngertips
  • Are Sewn Slings Stronger Than Knotted Ones?
  • When to Replace Climbing Webbing
  • Using Grip Dip To Color Code Gear
  • The Benefits of Cotton
  • How to Pull a Rappel Rope
  • How to Properly Orient a Carabiner Gate
  • Are My Fuzzy Quickdraws Safe?
  • How to Stretch Climbing Shoes
  • Are 1/2-inch bolts really better than 3/8-inch?
  • Should I Resole My Rock Shoes?
  • Hand Drill Advice
  • Lonely Climber Looking for Woman
  • Is My Invented Knot Safe?
  • Difference Between Double and Twin Ropes
  • Dealing With an Argumentative Partner
  • Will Antifreeze Ruin Rope?
  • Why Is a Rack Called a Rack?
  • Rock Shoes For a Big Guy
  • Do They Kill Geese To Get Down?
  • How to Wash a Rope
  • Do Cam Teeth Do Anything?
  • Can I Fix Delaminated Rock Shoes?
  • Can I Mix a Static With a Dynamic Rope for Rappelling?
  • Should You Lower Or Rap Through Anchors?
  • Should You Clip the Belay As Your First Lead Pro?
  • How Should The Middle Man Tie In?
  • How Do I Get a Good Climbing Man?
  • Do Falls Weaken Bolts?
  • Should I Rope Solo?
  • Should I Angle Ice Screws Down?
  • How Should Old Climbers Train?
  • Can I Make a Belay Loop?
  • Reusiing Ice Screw Holes
  • Overcoming Fear of Falling
  • Choosing a Stove Fuel
  • Will My Hiking Boots Work With Crampons?
  • Do Heavy People Shock Load the Rope?
  • Can Offset Cams Subsitute for Regular Cams?
  • Can I Resling My Cams Myself?
  • Are Older Alien Cams Safe?
  • Antifreeze
  • The Truth About Climbing Supplements
  • Can I Make My Leashed Tools, Leashless?
  • Rope Stretch Facts
  • How To Cut a Rope Without a Knife
  • Secrets of the Toprope
  • How to Sharpen Crampons
  • Should I Become a Climbing Guide?
  • Preventing Climbing Rope Wear
  • How to Remove an Old Bolt
  • How to Customize Ice Tool Picks
  • Double Rope Facts
  • Do It Yourself Fruit Boots
  • Climbing Rope Sheath Slippage
  • Rockfall Safety
  • Do Screamers Work?
  • Defining the Cheater Stick and Stick Clip
  • Climbing Skin Care
  • Selecting a Gym Rope
  • Quick Links for Climbing
  • Are Russian Cams Good?
  • When To Retire Climbing Gear and Ropes
  • Should I Get a Link Cam?
  • How to Get a Climbing Mate
  • Will Dog Urine Harm My Rope?
  • Using Steel Carabiners for Fixed Quickdraws
  • Petzl Tibloc and Climbing Rope Sheath Damage
  • Overcoming Anger
  • Fixing a Spinning Bolt
  • Video Spotlight
    Secundo Route - Sugar Loaf
    Secundo Route - Sugar Loaf

    Should I Angle Ice Screws Down?

    24-Jun-2010
    By Gear Guy

    I heard that ice screws should be angled slightly down to maximize the strength of the threads. If this is true, why don’t the threads run the full length of the screw, rather than just the first couple of inches?

    Like the existence of life after death or true love, the jury is still out on that one. Limited testing by Chris Harmston of Black Diamond and Craig Luebben about 10 years ago showed that ice screws with the hanger end angled down (negative angle) up to 20 degrees were stronger than screws with the hanger parallel to the ice or angled slightly up (positive angle). A negative angle does not, however, increase the strength of the threads; rather, it decreases the chance that the ice will blow out from under the screw.

    A negative-angle placement relies on the gripping power of the threads, which vary among screw designs: more and deeper threads equal more grip (presuming solid ice). A negative placement is stronger because the shaft of the screw cannot lever against and crush the ice beneath it like a bartender making a mojito. When the ice supporting a screw blows out, the shaft bends and the screw fails. There are, of course, other failure modes—in soft, rotten or hollow ice the screw will pop out like a bad cork.

    But before you start thinking negatively, know that the caveats to a negative-angle placement are as varied as the ice itself. For instance, how much do you angle the screw down? What is the ice like (rotten surface, air pockets, mushy)? In bomber ice it might be better to angle the screw down or perpendicular to the predicted angle of loading (more guesswork? … Noo!), although just about any screw placement in solid ice is going to be bomber. 

    The long and short of it is you need Old E (experience, that is … not the stuff quaffed by Valley bums) to be able to safely judge the quality of any ice-screw placement. Since this is as realistic as conducting your own auto- crash tests, use common sense to guide your ice-pro placements (looks like you’re a goner). 

    Other tidbits to glean from Harmston and Luebben’s testing are: Use the proper length of screw—tie offs break. And ice hooks don’t hold, although I’ll still use them as quickie pro to cover me while placing a real screw. 

    Running threads along the entire length of the screw, like time machines, could be a brilliant idea. Why haven’t the manufacturers thought of this? They have, actually. Most screws are or should be designed for optimal placement ease and strength. Running threads the entire length of the screw would mean you’d have more resistance when placing it. Since getting a screw in as quickly as possible is usually your priority, once you’re on the sharp end a screw with full-length threads is suddenly going to seem like a shitty idea. Moreover, in solid ice, a screw with full threads isn’t going to be stronger than a screw with partial threads because neither is likely to pull out. In poor ice, full threads might increase security simply because they will grip into more ice. Then again, in bad ice you’re more likely to be saved by an angel than by a screw. Besides, who falls on ice?

    I suggest that instead of staying up at night pondering the merits of screw designs, your time will be better spent on your knees begging the Almighty for divine intervention next time you’ve got a screw loose out on the business end and it all goes to shit. Next!

    Reader's Commentary:

    Don't want to use Facebook, but still want to comment? We have you covered:

    Add Your Comments to this article:
    Hello